Yeah - at some stations you have to sit in the last carriage to get off. And with these new Quiet Carriages, it is sort've shoving all the noisy people into just 4 carriages. In my opinion, it would be better to shove all the people who want quietness into their own carriage, rather than forcing all noisy people togethor.
I mean, after school, there are about 700-1000 school kids from a variety of schools who catch the 3.26 train from Gosford to Sydney. Alot of them need to sit in the last carriage to get off. And it seems unfair that they have to move between carriage for the sake of another luxury. And then, you are still shoving hundreds of noisy kids into just 4 carriages. There will be so many more bags in the way, so many more groups in the way, so many more kids in the way then there were before. Whilst in the quiet carriages there will be hardly anyone. Already with only 2 cars, I notice that only about 15 - 20 people are sitting there. Throughout the rest of the train, there are hardly any other elderly or adults. Now, those same people will just have way more space, whilst this policy crams hundreds of loud and boisterous kids togethor into four carriages when we already take up 100% in 6 carriages.
[15%] [60%] [ 70%] [70%] [80%] [80%] [90%] [10%]
With the new policy:
[10%] [80%] [90%] [10%] [10%] [100%] [100%] [10%]
And thats after Woy Woy when alot of the kids have already gotten off.