How to 3d model oval typed roofs?

  cityrail-rulez Chief Train Controller

G'day everyone!

Just looking for some advice on how to make those old fashioned oval type roofs on passenger carriages
in either Blender or TSM

I'm really stuck on making them!
Regards, Phil

Edit: this is the type of oval roofs I am referring to!
team-ALCO - Quality Australian Add-Ons for MS Train Simulator: NSWGR 36 Class Passewnger Stock
QLD CARRIAGES/ROLLINGSTOCK - Queensland's Great Trains ( comment see AL passenger carriage at this link!

Sponsored advertisement

  superheatedsteam Deputy Commissioner

Location: Perth, WA
Hi Phil,

For a simple curve like on the BL, BGV and CLV type of roof then a cylinder to the radius of the curve is what I would use. Remove the faces you don't need then extrude along normals or use the solidify modifier to add thickness of the roof.

For compound curves like the SX carriages then I would still start with a cylinder the scale it flat in the vertical axis and for the edges at the sides where the curve is a sharper radius I would manipulate the vertices manually and eyeball it.

As for the curved ends, I would just extrude the ends of the 'main' roof section and the scale or manually manipulate the vertices to resemble your references.

BLV type roofs are basically 2 different roofs joined together. I would make them as separate objects and then join them together.

If using blender then you only need to model half the roof with the mirror modifier applied along the Y axis. This way you only have to model one side and the other side will be identical. Once the roof is finished, 'Apply' the mirror modifier to create a single roof mesh.

There is no 'right' or 'wrong' way but 'any' way that ends up with the result you want. There are heaps of tutorials on youtube on making curves using different techniques. Unless you have shop drawings or you can measure your subject personally with a tape measure, you are inevitably going to end up having to 'eyeball' it. The old adage if it looks right then it is right holds true here.

At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I suggest using Shape File Manager to view other models in wire frame mode to see how other modellers have built their roofs and do the same on your models.


  cityrail-rulez Chief Train Controller

Thanks heaps Marek Smile

Really appreciate your advice mate Cool I will give it a shot and see what I can come up with in Blender and work it out in TSM
I did try using the cylinder without the ends and filled in the faces, so far I can only model the arched roof type but just couldn't get the oval roof modelled it using bevel, it was stressing me out mate that's why I created this thread because I was truly stuck on what I wanted to do

I forgot about shape file manager! I better install it, I haven't got everything installed on my Windows 10 machine as I did on my Windows 7 machine

Thanks for the heads up mate, I do appreciate your good sound advice
Regards, Phil Smile

Sponsored advertisement

Subscribers: superheatedsteam

Display from:   

Quick Reply

We've disabled Quick Reply for this thread as it was last updated more than six months ago.