Perth train passengers most satisfied rail commuters in Australia: survey
Rail sounds spectator safety alert
Hunter workers in running to build new train fleet
Rail access deal on arbitration track
Manage grain on rail issue: WAFarmers
Growers fear January rail access issues
West Australian rail network operator says state government investment needed to reopen Tier 3 rail freight lines
FMG mulls railway expansion
Western Australia needs a state-wide infrastructure plan to support mining and resources growth, says peak industry body
Historic Golden Mile Loopline Railway from Kalgoorlie to Boulder in WA Goldfields set to live again
THE CBH Group was not charged more than 'ceiling costs' of more than $486.9 million for the three years its grain trains operated on WA's freight rail network under interim access agreements, an independent review has found.
Redacted documents put up on its website last week by the Economic Regulation Authority (ERA) show it engaged Sydney accounting firm Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu last August to conduct a statutory three-year review of the rail access agreements between CBH and freight rail network operator Arc Infrastructure - previously named Brookfield Rail.
In a letter dated December 10, 2020, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu partner Yvonne van Wijk informed both Arc chief financial officer Mark Sealey and ERA executive director regulations and inquiry Paul Kelly, that no "exemptions" to what is known as the 'Overpayment Rules' were identified in calendar years 2017, 2018 and 2019.
Ms van Wijk's letter indicated the review - required under provisions of the Rail (Access) Code 2000 to theoretically encourage rail usage competition by ensuring freight rail users are not charged more than predetermined upper limit 'ceiling costs' - covered 15 sections of the rail network CBH sought access to.
But while the review complied with the requirements specified by the ERA, Ms van Wijk pointed out "the agreed-upon procedures did not constitute either a reasonable assurance (audit) or limited assurance (review) engagement in accordance with the Auditing and Assurance Standards Board standards".
Despite this, the ERA referred to the review as an "audit" and said "the audit report found no instances of non-compliance (with Overpayment Rules)".
As previously reported in Farm Weekly, in November 2019, CBH concluded six years of negotiation with first Brookfield and then Arc, signing a confidential seven-year rail access agreement for grain trains on 15 train paths, which came into effect on January 1 last year and is due to expire at the end of 2026.
Prior to that agreement, CBH grain trains had operated under a series of interim agreements and agreement extensions, beginning on January 1, 2017, while negotiations continued with Brookfield and Arc over the longer-term access agreement.
Those interim agreements were technically the first signed under the State's Rail (Access) Code 2000 so are therefore the first subject to a three-year review under the Overpayment Rules provisions of the code.
CBH is still the only freight rail network user to negotiate an access agreement under the rail code.
Before 2017 it ran its grain trains under a private agreement - every other rail user has a private access agreement with Arc - outside of the code.
The overpayment review only applies to access agreements under the code.
Before access negotiations can begin under the code, the ERA has to approve total price 'ceiling costs', which includes both rail access fees and a tonnage-per-kilometre usage charge.
Access fees and usage charges can vary for different sections of line depending on things like frequency of usage proposed and density of other rail traffic.
A November last year approval of adjusted costs - also redacted - on the ERA website showed the ERA-approved ceiling cost for CBH to use some of 20 sections of the freight rail network in 2017 was $179.9m.
The document also shows the approved ceiling costs for CBH to use some of 19 sections of the rail network in 2018 and 2019 were $163.2m and $143.8m respectively.
This article first appeared on www.farmweekly.com.au
About this website
Railpage version 3.10.0.0037
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest is © 2003-2021 Interactive Omnimedia Pty Ltd.
You can syndicate our news using one of the RSS feeds.